Monday, February 22, 2010

The Balibo Five - A New Zealand perspective...

New Zealand government "Beehive" and...Image via Wikipedia

The Balibo Five - A New Zealand Perspective...

The Balibo Five as they have become known were a group of journalists working on assignment for an Australian television channel, Channel Seven. There were five in the initial group who were shot, gunned down, executed by Indonesian troops, or caught in a crossfire between them and rebels. Just who were the insurgents has ben a matter of opinion for decades. There was another journalist who came to investigate the missing journalists, who was also killed in the area. It has been claimed also that Indonesian troops responsible for the deaths were special forces troops whose role was to prepare the ground for the actual invasion forces. President Suharto allegedly did not want flags or identification markings on these particular troops.That has to be treated as hearsay evidence at this stage until the current enquiry proves otherwise.

The Balibo Five comprised two Australian and two British journalists and a New Zealnd cameraman, Gary Cunningham. It has been claimed the five men were killed to prevent them from reporting to the outside world the prevalent abuse of local Timorese citizens by Indonesian special forces troops.

What has followed for the family of Gary Cunningham has been three decades of injustice, lack of information, and a shameful lack of action by the New Zealand Government. The latter has, for reasons of their own, failed to give a satisfactory account of the Balibo Five massacre. Successive administrations apparently just shelved all information concerning the late Gary Cunningham and his colleagues over many years. Australians were also denied the facts starting with former Australian prime minister Gough Whitlam's denial. An existing Australian investigation should soon make these facts available. The Indonesians are also bemused by the apparent inaction over the years.

Gary Cunningham's family has been frustrated over many years by the failure of apparent gutless New Zealand Government administrations to reveal the truth they were, undoubtably, well aware of. A memorial to the late Gary Cunningham will be installed at Charles Plimmer Park, Mount Victoria, in the New Zealand capital, Wellington City. Mr Cunningham lived in Wellington until he ws 21 years old. A commemorative plaque, park bench and tree will comprise the memorial at the park. Gary's late father Jim, died in 2001 and would undoubtably be pleased with the memorial.

An Indonesian Committee for Human Rights, Maire Leadbeater, who organised the memorial with the Media Freedom Committee secretary, reportedly called Gary Cunningham a "true hero". To the East TImorese people he is a martyr.

A war crimes investigation was carried out by the Australian Federal police last year and what has been described as a "powerful film", Balibo, was released on Feb 18 2010, this year.

It is hoped the local memorial would provoke some action from the so-far gutless New Zealand government, which has not been any better than its predecessors and has turned its back on this incident, and should at least give some public recognition, something shared by Wellington City mayor, Kerry Prentergast - but as they say, don't hold your breath!

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Sunday, February 21, 2010

The Untold Story of the Balibo Five: A killing field in East Timor

DiliImage via Wikipedia

The Untold Story Of The Balibo Five

The depressing saga of Australian efforts to establish the fate of the five Australia-based TV reporters killed in Balibo illustrates the bind that Australian diplomats had created for themselves.

They knew Indonesian forces carried out the attack on Balibo and had been warned by Harry Tjan, the director of the quasi-academic think tank that was their key source of information on Indonesia's intentions towards Portuguese Timor. But they wouldn't say so publicly, for fear of cutting off their source and jeopardising relations with Jakarta.

Death Of "Balibo Five" Was Premeditated War Crime 20/11/2007
Troops Covered Up Murder Of 'Balibo Five' 16/02/2007
Report by Inspector General into the Balibo Five 04/06/2002
Blick report into Balibo five 04/06/2002
Results powered by More Related Stories >>>

On October 13, 1975, Tjan told the Australian embassy in Jakarta that Indonesian forces were finally about to enter the territory.

The main thrust would begin on October 15, through Balibo and Maliana/Atsabe. President Suharto had insisted "no Indonesian flag" be used, giving Jakarta the cloak of deniability.

Portuguese Timor's ordeal was about to enter a new and terrible phase. The five journalists had little more than two days to live.

In Canberra on October 15, Timor dominated Prime Minister Gough Whitlam's discussions with visiting Malaysian Prime Minister Abdul Razak. Whitlam complained of biased Australian media reporting. The trouble was the reporters had easy access to Dili and Baucau, he said, but didn't go to the border areas, so they gave a one-sided picture. The five reporters, now in Balibo on the border, had only hours to live.

On the morning of October 16, Indonesian troops disguised as Timorese anti-Fretilin forces attacked Balibo. The five reporters were killed.

In the documents released yesterday, the first reference to the journalists' fate is a transcript of an ABC news item on October 17, reporting the journalists were missing. The transcript was sent to the embassy in Jakarta, requesting urgent inquiries. So began extraordinary efforts by Australian diplomats to establish what happened to the journalists, which at times bordered on farcical charade.

As well as not wanting to jeopardise their Indonesian sources, the diplomats wouldn't compromise more secret sources. It is known Australian intelligence agencies that intercepted Indonesian radio traffic were aware of the deaths on October 16, and that the Federal Government was informed that night. All references to intelligence material have been expunged from the documents.

On October 17, when Gerald Stone of Channel Nine rang the embassy asking

if it had more information on the journalists, he was told nothing more was available.

The Indonesian Foreign Ministry and Tjan both told the embassy that any information on Balibo would have to come from anti-Fretilin forces, in line with the fiction that Jakarta was not involved in the Balibo operation. "We said we understood this completely," the embassy said in a cable on October 17.

The following day ambassador Richard Woolcott cabled Canberra: "As you will know (half a line of intelligence material is expunged) it now appears likely that at least four and possible all five of the Australian journalists were killed in the fighting in and around Balibo."

If true, this was a "sad and dreadful development".

The cable made no other reference to remorse for the journalists or their families. Rather, Woolcott was concerned about the risk of "serious consequences" if Australian public opinion was inflamed "if it appears that Australian casualties are the result of Indonesian intervention".

The cable went on to shift blame for the reporters' fate, pointing the finger at Canberra's responsibility to alert Australians to the dangers of the border area.

Woolcott's cable prompted a stinging response from Foreign Affairs head Alan Renouf, who replied personally, complaining about the "tone and language", which was "quite inappropriate and is resented here".

On October 19, Woolcott had a frosty encounter with Indonesian Foreign Minister Adam Malik, who was angry and dismissive. Any information on the journalists would have to come from anti-Fretilin forces, not Indonesia,

and he raised the question of whether the journalists had worn Fretilin uniforms.

In the following weeks, Australian diplomats engaged in a fruitless and humiliating series of representations with Jakarta officials, seeking some confirmation on the fate of the journalists that could satisfy distraught families and an increasing alarmed Australian public.

On October 20, Tjan told the embassy that four bodies had been found at Balibo. The embassy passed on the information to Canberra but, because of the source, warned it should not be used in any public statements.

Daily the embassy contacted the Indonesian Foreign Ministry, which daily held out hopes for information. "Each day we are disappointed," the embassy reported on October 23.

The embassy suspected information on the "missing" journalists could be produced at the "drop of a hat", but said "influential elements", apparently the BAKIN intelligence agency, "are clearly preventing us from receiving it".

Eleven days after the reporters' deaths, a BAKIN officer told the embassy they were dead, but this could not be publicly released as it would imply Indonesian involvement in the Balibo attack.

Final confirmation of their deaths, if not how they died, came on November 12, when Woolcott met Lieutenant-General Yoga Sugama, head of BAKIN, who handed over four boxes of remains. The embassy doctor "confirmed to the best of his knowledge they were human remains".



Reblog this post [with Zemanta]